Dog & Cat Cone Alternatives: Beyond the Cone of Shame

Pet care & safety
An adorable dog is seen wearing a traditional dog cone collar more humorously known as cone of shame. But what's not humorous is the expression the poor dog is wearing, its owner might have to look for dog cone alternatives the next time around.

As Luna, our curious and playful tabby cat, awoke from her spay surgery, she found herself disoriented and frightened by the strange new sensation around her neck. A large, plastic cone collar, often referred to as the “cone of shame” has been put on her as a safety precaution, but to her it felt more like a punishment than a tool for healing. This experience is all too familiar for many pet owners who have had to watch their furry friends struggle with the cumbersome and uncomfortable Elizabethan collar, or “E-collar”, more humorously known as the “cone of shame”. 

The Elizabethan collar is a type of protective medical device designed to prevent pets from licking, biting, or scratching their wounds, surgical sites, or irritated hot spots. The traditional E-collar is made of rigid plastic and has a cone-shaped design that extends beyond the pet's nose, creating a barrier between its mouth and the affected area. While these collars serve an essential purpose in the healing process, they can also be a source of stress and discomfort for your pet. The rigid plastic can make it difficult for animals to navigate their surroundings, eat, drink, or sleep comfortably. The cone can also amplify sounds and limit peripheral vision, adding to their anxiety.  

Keep Your Pet Safe and Comfortable During Recovery with These Dog and Cat Cone Alternatives 

As pet owners, it can be heartbreaking to watch our furry friends struggle with these traditional E-collars or cone of shame. Fortunately, there are now several ways to reduce your pet's stress while they're recovering, and these dog and cat cone alternatives might help do just that. By exploring these options and working with your veterinarian, you can help your furry friend feel more at ease during the recovery process. 

Soft Pet Cone Collars 

Soft e-collars are a great alternative to the usual cone of shame, providing the same protection while allowing your pet to sleep, eat, and move around more comfortably. They may cost a bit more, but the improved comfort is well worth it. You will be amazed by how nice the upgrade to the soft version is. It's still covering the same field of vision, and it is much less frustrating for them with less wear and tear on your walls (and your nerves).  

Pros: 

  • More comfortable and less stressful for pets compared to traditional plastic cones 

  • Allows for better visibility and range of motion 

  • Machine washable for easy cleaning  

Cons: 

  • May not be sturdy enough for determined pets who may still be able to access wound sites 

  • Can be more expensive than traditional plastic cones 

Inflatable Dog Cone Collars 

The inflatable dog collar makes your dog and cat look a bit like he's lost out at sea in need of rescuing. They are another effective option for preventing your pets from reaching, chewing or licking problem areas. While they may not be suitable for every situation, most dogs and cats adapt to them quite well.  

Pros: 

  • Comfortable and less restrictive than traditional cones 

  • Allows for full visibility, with no obstruction. 

  • Easy to store when deflated  

Cons: 

  • May not provide adequate protection for head or face wounds 

  • Can be punctured or deflated by determined and energetic pets 

Recovery Suits and Sleeves 

For wounds or surgical sites on the body, recovery suits and sleeves can provide protection without the need for a collar. These recovery garments come in various designs to cover specific areas like the different legs, feet, or the torso (they look a little like a wet suit) allowing your pet to move freely while keeping the affected area protected during the healing process.  

Pros: 

  • Can prevent your dog or cat from licking or biting the wound and/or surgical site without restricting head movement 

  • Allows for normal eating, drinking, and sleeping 

  • Can be worn for extended periods  

 Cons: 

  • May not be suitable for very active pets who could dislodge the garment 

  • Some pets may find the garments uncomfortable or stressful 

DIY Dog Cone Collar Ideas 

If you're in a pinch and need a quick solution, you can create a makeshift dog cone using items like a bath towel, bubble wrap, cardboard, pool noodles—you can even use a travel pillow. However, it's crucial to ensure that your pet is comfortable, can breathe easily, and that the cone allows enough room for eating and drinking. Keep in mind that these DIY options may not be as durable or effective as store-bought alternatives and should only be used for short periods under close supervision.  

Choosing the Right Dog and Cat Cone Alternative  

When choosing a dog or cat cone alternative, proper fit is vital to ensure both comfort and effectiveness. Measure your pet's neck circumference and compare it to the product sizing chart to choose the appropriate size. Ensure the device fits snugly but allows room for two fingers between the collar and neck for safety. It should be tight enough to prevent your pet from slipping out but not so tight that it restricts breathing or causes discomfort. And the cone should not extend more than 2 inches past their face so they can eat and drink. 

Before purchasing any cone alternative, consult with your veterinarian. They can advise on which option might work best based on your pet's specific injury, temperament, and lifestyle. Your vet can also provide guidance on how long your pet needs to wear the cone, typically ranging from 7-14 days, depending on the type of injury or surgery. It's crucial to monitor your pet closely while using any dog or cat cone alternative, especially DIY versions, to ensure it is working effectively and not causing any additional issues. If you notice your pet is still able to lick or chew at their wound or the device is bothering them, contact your vet for further advice. 

Preventing the Need for the ‘Cone of Shame’ 

Now, as Luna, our curious and playful tabby cat finally adjusts to her new, more comfortable recovery suit, she's a reminder that while the "cone of shame" may sometimes be necessary, it doesn't have to be a source of stress for our furry friends. But aside from the dog and cat cone alternatives, the best course of action you can still take is to prevent your pets from needing an e-collar in the first place. Regular check-ups, timely treatment of injuries or illnesses, and maintaining a safe environment can help reduce the likelihood of your pets requiring these dog cone collars.  

Having a plan in place is key to responsible pet ownership, but life doesn’t always go according to plan. Pet insurance can provide a financial safety net for unexpected veterinary expenses. Consider investing in a pet insurance plan for your dog or cat which offers comprehensive coverage for both accidents and illnesses, so that you can focus on their recovery, rather than stressing about the bill. An optional, non-insurance wellness care can help you budget for veterinary expenses and stay on top of preventive care to keep your furry friend healthy.  

If, despite our best efforts, our furry companions do need to wear the “cone of shame”, it’s nice to remember that there’s no actual shame in it – you’re being a responsible pet parent and aiding in their healing process. But, if we can find a safe and comfortable alternative to the traditional plastic E-collar, our pets will undoubtedly appreciate the extra effort. Working closely with our veterinarians, we can determine the best cone collar alternative for our pet's specific needs, ensuring a more comfortable and stress-free recovery.